Can you survive An Unholy Return: The 31 Games of Halloween?
- DAILY REVIEWS -
Cover Critic
The Cover Critic Beheads Mortal Kombat
By Cyril Lachel     |   Posted on April 11, 2011   |   Episode 77 (Show Archive)  

   
They say you shouldn't judge a book by its cover. But since I've never heard that expression used against video games I figure that it's open season on the box art you see every day. In this episode we take a very special look at Mortal Kombat. With the brand new refresh coming out next week, we thought it would be fun to throw a bunch of artwork at the Cover Critic and see what he says. GET OVER HERE ... and join us as we look at all nine of the main entries in the Mortal Kombat universe. FINISH HIM!
Mortal Kombat
[ System: Genesis - 1993 - Final Rating: B+ ]
We begin our eighteen year journey by looking at the game that started it all -- Mortal Kombat. Instead of focusing on amazing hand-drawn graphics and silky smooth animation, Midway's action game was full of brutal violence and photo realistic characters. It spit in the face of every video game convention and turned the spotlight of the U.S. government on the entire industry. This 1993 home release was met with just as much controversy. While the Sega Genesis version featured every gruesome fatality move, the Super NES game was censored. This was the Genesis game to own in 1993, making it an excellent first stop on our adventure.

Although the game was ported to a half dozen consoles, this Genesis box is indicative of the overall design. There's nothing fancy about the cover art, just the game's title and the Mortal Kombat emblem. The game warns you that it's MA-13, meaning that it's not meant for anybody under 13 years old. The artwork's color scheme works well when set against the late generation Genesis logo. Best of all, there's nothing about this cover that would offend the average parent buying it for a holiday gift. Without inspecting the screenshots on the back or asking the store clerk, it's easy to see how kids could sucker adults into buying this innocent looking game. I like that. I also like this cover. It's a solid design, but it lacks that certain spark that would put it over the line.

Mortal Kombat II
[ System: Super NES - 1994 - Final Rating: A ]
Now this is the spark I'm talking about! Mortal Kombat II is not only the best game in the series, but also a triumph of box art design. Acclaim was not a company known for subtlety, yet here we have an atmospheric design that evokes the best of classic box art. The design references the original game, using the large Mortal Kombat emblem and simple logo. What it adds is a stormy background, which goes a long way to set the tone of this gruesome one-on-one fighting game.

What I love about this cover is how it commands attention without resorting to ultra-violence or half-naked women. And believe me, Acclaim could have easily gone in both of those directions, there's no end to the gratuitous violence in Mortal Kombat. But they restrained, instead choosing to go with a design that is even more powerful. It's not the kind of artistic choice we see on game boxes very often, which may be why Mortal Kombat II continues to stick with me. Street Fighter II may have been a better game, but Mortal Kombat had better cover art ... for now.

Mortal Kombat 3
[ System: PlayStation - 1995 - Final Rating: F ]
We go from the best Mortal Kombat cover to the worst. Whoever was in charge of putting together this mess of a box deserves to be fired. Then again, considering how fickle the games industry is, he probably has been fired numerous times. I hate to consider how the instability is hurting his wife and children. On the other hand, he could be the kind of screw-up that never gets fired no matter how bad it gets. I take it back; I want this tasteless jerk to get the axe ... preferably one of the Kombatants using that axe to cut him in two.

By 1995 Mortal Kombat had turned into that douche bag friend you hang out with that always wants to hit on girls at the bar. He's too cool to use his full name; he goes with an abbreviation all the way. He doesn't even have to get made up, that's how cool he is. He just puts on a skull mask and looks real creepy. Hmm ... on second thought, that seems to be where this analogy breaks down. I doubt that anybody associated with the production of this game had anything to do with this PlayStation cover. This has the look and feel of something slapped together at the last minute by an outside company. Perhaps this is what Sony honestly thought would sell the game. Or maybe they just didn't care. After all, everybody knew that Mortal Kombat 3 was a huge get and at the end of the day that's all they needed. I, on the other hand, need something more than a red skull and an abbreviated title. One of the laziest covers of all time.

Mortal Kombat 4
[ System: PlayStation - 1998 - Final Rating: D+ ]
The late 1990s marked a tough time for the Mortal Kombat franchise. After having so much success early on, Midway's popular fighting series was having an identity crisis. Thanks to the success of Tekken and Virtua Fighter, arcade goers were giving the cold shoulder to traditional 2D fighters. This left Mortal Kombat and Street Fighter out in the cold, forcing both companies to try something radically different. Feeling the pressure, Midway gave in and turned their flagship franchise into a 3D fighter. The results were decidedly bad. Not only did the game look bad (even by 1998 standards), but it never once felt like a Mortal Kombat game. Even the return of fan favorite characters is enough to make this anything above a sub-par fighting game.

Sadly the game's cover art only helps to reinforce how low the series had sunk. Even with three characters, this cover is too crowded for its own good. Worse yet, Rayden's new design should have been a warning for anybody on the fence about the polygonal facelift. Goro isn't much better. He's mostly covered by shadows, but not in an especially menacing way. He also appears to be protecting that briefcase from Pulp Fiction. Making things even more confusing, Goro was nowhere to be seen in the Mortal Kombat 4 arcade cabinet. Yet judging by this cover art you would think that he is the main character. I would say that unknowing gamers were likely disappointed when they got home, but everything is disappointing when it comes to Mortal Kombat 4.

Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance
[ System: PlayStation 2 - 2002 - Final Rating: B+ ]
After the disaster that was Mortal Kombat 4, Midway decided to take a good long break. It took Ed Boon's troupe five years to reinvent the Mortal Kombat franchise. Although it remained a 3D fighter (cribbing off of Namco's popular Soul Calibur series), Deadly Alliance was able to successfully reinvent itself in a way the last game could not. It didn't feel like the Mortal Kombat of old, but that wasn't a bad thing. The controls were replaced with weapon-based combat, new stage fatalities and a graphic engine that did the series justice. Mortal Kombat was back in a big way.

I like this cover art, it conveys the exact message Midway was going after. Mortal Kombat is back and this is the start of a new trilogy. The box art plays homage to the original games, keeping a simple design that is nothing more than the series' emblem. In this case the Mortal Kombat emblem is is being crushed by that giant "V" (this is the fifth game after all) like a nutcracker at Christmas. The blood at the bottom of the "V" reminds you that in Mortal Kombat ANYTHING goes.
MORE RECENT DEFUNCT GAMES ARTICLES ...


EGM'S BEST REVIEWED GAMES OF 1989

Mario, Mega Man, Lolo & More!
NINTENDO POWER'S FAV SNES GAMES

The Best Reviewed 16-Bit Games!



PLAYSTATION 4 REVIEW

Snake Pass
SWITCH REVIEW

Thumper
STEAM REVIEW

Little Nightmare

comments powered by Disqus